1833-1835 Benjamin F. Pike - 1st Elected Sheriff
|
| 1835-1837 Michael Bartlett |
1902-1906 W. George Heider |
| 1837-1839 Charles Eames |
1906-1910 Edward Kittelson |
| 1839-1841 Lucius Wells |
1910-1914 O. L. Bruner |
| 1841-1847 Lemuel Andrews |
1914-1918 George H.Richmond |
| 1847-1851 Samuel S. Guyer |
1918-1918 Jake Wiggers (Shot) |
| 1851-1853 T. B. Gorton |
1918-1922 John G. Miller |
| 1853-1855 A.F. Swander |
1922-1926 Clarence L. Edwards |
| 1855-1857 T. B. Gorton |
1926-1930 Howard Gregg |
| 1857-1859 E. M. Beardsley |
1930-1934 Fred R. Schlueter |
| 1859-1861 M. D. Merill |
1934-1938 Rudolph W. Kropp |
| 1861-1863 David Hawes |
1938-1942 Fred R. Schlueter |
| 1863-1865 C. A. McLaughlin |
1942-1946 Joe Schneider |
| 1865-1867 M. D. Merrill |
1946-1950 Claude J. Taylor |
| 1867-1869 John Peetz |
1950-1954 Morris E. Muhleman |
| 1869-1871 William Drury |
1954-1958 Joe Schneider |
| 1871-1874 William Payne |
1958-1962 Howard Dieterich |
| 1874-1876 August Huesing |
1962-1966 Einer G. Fredrickson |
| 1876-1879 Josiah L. Perkins |
1966-1970 William R. Boyle |
| 1879-1882 J. F. Akrum |
1970-1977 Joe Schneider |
| 1882-1886 J. M. Reticker |
1977-1978 James L. Shaw |
| 1886-1890 T. S. Silvas |
1978-1982 Randy E. Heaton |
| 1890-1894 C. D. Gordon |
1982-1989 Gordon A. Powell |
| 1894-1898 Fred C. Heminway |
1989-1990 Michael T. Green |
| 1898-1902 Levi F. Cralle |
1990-2006 Michael L. Grchan |
| 2006 - 2010 Michael T. Huff |
2010 - Present Jeff Boyd |
